Maman Poulet | Clucking away crookedly through media, politics and life

Access is more than a ramp

March 6th, 2012 · Disability

Luke Kelly Melia is 13 years old and in primary school in Cavan. Well he was in school until he got an assistance dog and the school refused to allow him bring it to school. I first read about Luke in January and had not heard anything since and thought the matter had been sorted. However I was informed today that he is still not allowed to bring the dog to school until there is a policy agreed and a consultation process is concluded so he is being home schooled. The school have had more than 8 weeks to get the policy written.

Luke’s dog (Aidan) is trained and provided by Dogs for the Disabled.

The dog gives Luke a lot of confidence when he walks. He doesn’t fall down as much. He’s written a letter to President Higgins about it. He and his family asked the Department and the Minister to help but they have not acted and said it is up to the school to decide if the dog can be permitted. (I’m sorry Luke, President Higgins can’t do much either but I’m sure someone is taking notice!!!)

There is no further response from the school on the matter and I’m finding it hard to understand what the problem is? The dog is trained to an international standard.

Is it children with allergies, a teacher with a phobia or a fear of a distraction? It’s fairly simple to say to all the children that the dog is working and not a toy and to leave him alone. Luke would have been trained to use him and the dog is trained to be obedient. Perhaps they think the dog is a fashion accessory and everyone will want to bring one to school. All this integration is grand till the disabled start looking for rights eh and wanting to express them? In fact the problem might be that people with disabilities don’t have automatic rights in Ireland and only 62% of people think that people with physical disabilities should attend the same schools as those without disabilities. (NDA 2012)

Given the growing number of children with disabilities using trained assistance dogs for mobility, safety and community integration one would hope (in vain) that all schools are developing policies on the matter. Guide dogs for people with visual impairments are permitted in buildings and services and indeed there are cases on the matter which have been heard by the Equality Tribunal.

I look forward to hearing more about what the problems with meeting Luke’s needs are. Or if there is more to the story. Actually I would not rather have to hear more or interfere with Luke’s privacy and just hear the matter is sorted.

Share

» 12 CommentsTags:

Three years on the circle is complete and still turning

March 3rd, 2012 · Irish Media, Irish Politics, MSM, Social Media

Three years ago myself and a number of other bloggers attended the Fianna Fáil Ard Fheis, liveblogged, (It’s amazing to read it back) took photos, video , blogged and encouraged people in attendance to tweet and engage.

We were looked at a bit strangely as we were there for the sake of doing it. OK I was there for some craic too. (Gavin Sheridan now works for Storyful and Mark Coughlan is working in RTE and freelancing.)

This year the Irish Times is liveblogging, shooting video and generally being all interactive. I’m not attending this year as I am ill but I can still keep up to date with what is going on. Other press tweet and take pictures without thinking about it and lots of delegates are commenting online about what is taking place officially and unofficially.

There has been a lot of comment on media diversity, development and survival in Ireland in the past few months, I’ve even been involved in some of it. However I’m still more interested in what we talk about and that we inform ourselves and others than in how we do it. The matter of doing it does interest me. The ‘who is paying for it and how it will be paid for’ question is one which seems has no clear answer yet.

Three years is a very long time in media history. Fair play to the Irish Times for the effort they are putting into covering the event online, I’m sure there are some in Tara Street who question its value like the bloggers who started out a few years ago were questioned when we arrived. I wonder how we will learn about and cover Ard Fheiseanna and other major events in years to come.

Share

» 1 CommentTags:

Abortion in Ireland – the Numbers

March 2nd, 2012 · Abortion, Irish Politics, Social Policy

150,000 women have left Ireland to access an abortion since 1980.  More facts on Ireland and Abortion in this animation from the Irish Family Planning Association released earlier this week.

Share

» 2 CommentsTags:··

Activating, Deactivating and the Unactivatable

February 27th, 2012 · Disability, Irish Politics

The Department of Social Protection are currently inviting organisations to tender for hosting projects to support people with disabilities into employment in the Borders, Midlands and West region.

The strategic aim of the Disability Activation Project is to increase the capacity and potential of people on Department of Social Protection disability/illness welfare payments to participate in the labour market, based on a case management approach.

There is 20 plus years experience in supporting people with disabilities into training, education and employment in Ireland.  Many pilot projects, best practice examples, multi million euro grants including EU funds awarded, launches had and reports published  and able bodied professionals employed to support people with disabilities through programmes.

I don’t know what has happened to the grand sum of that experience or if people with disabilities have been asked themselves about what has worked or not worked and what the barriers are. The unemployment rate amongst people with disabilities who would be capable of work is reported to be 70% – it’s hard to gauge because many people are not on the live register.  Unemployment is not just about not being able to get a job but also about the lack of supports for the cost of disability, transportation and personal assistance deficits and attitudes of potential employers.

This new activation initiative is happening as it is reported that next month eighteen staff many of who have disabilities are being made redundant from positions heavily subsidised by the state (Wage Support Scheme) who are employed by Rehab.  The positions in a recycling plant in Galway are being made redundant due to losses incurred in the plant.  Michael Clifford reports in the Irish Examiner that the employee’s union claim that the decision on who will be let go will not take their disabilities into account.  Decisions on who loses their job will depend on “productivity, teamwork and communications, attendance and punctuality, disciplinary records”.

That’s 18 deactivations (I’m using the word with a deep sense of irony) despite heavy state support and no record of efforts by the state funded charity to redeploy staff or reorganise the focus of the plant which is what the union are asking for with the help of the local community.

In 2010, the last year for which complete figures are available, the group had an income, including charitable donations, of €187m, of which €54.4m came from various state bodies. The group recorded a net surplus of €2.3m, up from €1.9m the previous year. Net assets in the same period increased from €51m to €56m.

The Wage Support scheme which funds up to two thirds of the cost of an hourly wage supports about 800 people with disabilities to remain in employment in both the private and not for profit sectors and encourages employers to take people on.  The rationale for the payment is that it is paid to employers to compensate them for the imputed productivity loss that employing a person with a disability might result in.  The more disabled employees you hire the more money you get.  From up to €10,748 for a firm employing one person with a disability to €16,122 per employee with a disability in firms employing twenty three or more people with a disability. Plus you can get funding to hire someone to support disabled employees in a workplace.

And yet the scheme means you are easily disposable too when companies are downsizing. If you are less productive you can be let go and the government agencies can’t insist you are kept on instead of someone who is able bodied and possibly more adaptable.

The Minister for Social Protection has recently announced that all the various disability employment supports are coming under an Employability Service.  Perhaps this will remove some of the vested interests and ‘patch watching’ which has developed over the years and see standards of support and service improve.  Like many of the other supports for people with disabilities these supports including job coaching have been farmed out to outside groups  – maybe the new National Entitlement and Employment Service will be open to all with skilled support whether you are disabled or able bodied.  And in this not so improbable situation those people who do not have the capacity to work will also be valued and supported in society and not disposed of or viewed as inactive or a drain on the state.

Share

» 1 CommentTags:

Healthcare policy in Ireland – a job for the boys

February 26th, 2012 · Irish Politics, Social Policy

On Friday the Minister for Health, Dr. James Reilly, announced the establishment of an implementation group on Universal Health Insurance.

The group according to the department will  ‘comprise a mix of those with executive responsibilities within our health service and external experts.’

The members appointed

  • Dr. Fergal Lynch, Department of Health (Chair)
  • Paul Barron, Department of Health
  • Tom Heffernan, Department of Public Expenditure and Reform
  • Liam Woods, National Director of Finance, HSE
  • Dr. Barry White, National Director for Clinical Strategy and Programmes, HSE
  • Brian Fitzgerald, Director of Finance, St. James’ Hospital and Joint Director of the HSE Patient Level Costing Project
  • Mark Moran, Former CEO of the Mater Private Hospital and former Chairman of the DoH/HSE Working Group on Reference Pricing and Generic Substitution
  • Prof. Reinhard Busse and Sarah Thomson, international experts working with the World Health Organisation, the European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies and others
  • Dr. Fergus O’Ferrall, Lecturer in Health Policy, Trinity College Dublin

That’s one woman. Out of ten.

The statement says that the group’s membership will will ‘be flexible and will be subject to periodic review as different stages in the implementation process are reached.’

Congratulations to the Minister on achieving such a feat with his first group despite the large numbers of women working in the health services and studying health systems and public administration delivery both here and abroad.

Share

» 7 CommentsTags: